CarMax Tallahassee

4.2 Google
Open Today:

11:00 AM - 8:00 PM

Google Customer Reviews

Joel Prosser

Feb 17, 2026

Rating:

I had the best experience purchasing a car that I’ve ever had here. I had the pleasure of working with Jenn, Dennis, and Ethan. They went the extra mile to make my trade in process easier than expected (as well as getting me more than I hoped), Jenn helped me find a car that I loved, while making sure it was something I could afford. I would recommend 10 stars if I could.

Kam Green

Feb 10, 2026

Rating:

I worked with Ron. He was fantastic and explained everything start to finish while managing to be quick as I had my kids with me (6 and 4). Very thorough review of my vehicle to sell and ensured the online quote was honored. I went by Saturday afternoon and they were very busy but Ron still made sure we got everything we needed in a timely manner.

Nicole Tamargo Icard

Jan 21, 2026

Rating:

Car buying without the stress? At CarMax, apparently yes. I bought a 2024 Toyota Corolla and had an amazing experience from start to finish. Huge shoutout to Renee Cherry, who was knowledgeable, patient, and refreshingly not pushy. She made the whole process smooth, easy, and even enjoyable (which feels illegal in car sales). No pressure, no gimmicks—just great service and a great car. If you’re shopping at CarMax Tallahassee, do yourself a favor and ask for Renee. 10/10 would recommend. 🚗✨

jennifer kupiszewski

Nov 23, 2025

Rating:

Dennis was amazing. He offered excellent customer service. Everything was clearly explained. He went above and beyond. The CarMax process was easy. When I had trouble customer service called me back on a Sunday and walked me through the issue. The offer on my trade was honored so need to haggle and the car we bought was exactly as promised. The car arrived earlier than promised but we were not available so CarMax held the car for a couple of days. Everything was so convenient. I will not buy a car another way. We bought a 2019 Nissan Platinum Pathfinder and we love it.

Danae Knorst

Apr 3, 2025

Rating:

Best car buying experience I’ve had. Went online, found the exact truck I wanted. Had shipped. It arrived early and was ready for me test drive the best day. Renee helped us every step of the way and we were in and out unbelievably quickly. No hassle whatsoever. No pressure. She was simply there to make my car buying experience easy and answered my many questions with expertise. The manager was also very nice and helpful. We couldn’t be more pleased with our vehicle. We got a great deal and will be returning when my son is ready to buy his first car. Folks, if you are in the market, just come here. You won’t regret it. Ask for Renee!