East Hills Subaru of Sayville

“I recently purchased a 2026 Subaru Crosstrek & I was very pleased with the whole experience. Jason Behlen was very professional & knowledgeable about the vehicles. The whole process from start to finish was very smooth. I highly recommend Jason to anyone looking to purchase a car.”

“If there were 100 stars it would still not be enough for the experience I received today!! I’ve leased many cars/trucks over the years and always get very anxious when it comes time to turn in my current vehicle and start the process over again. I simply can not stand the high pressure sale, how long the process takes, all the mind games, the price haggling etc. This time I completely switched gears and decided to go with a Subaru. I still had 3 months left on my current lease so naturally I was just going to ask questions. Within seconds of entering the dealership I was greeted with a warm welcome. I sat with Mike Chiofalo, I immediately clicked with him, I’m in the service industry and feel it is important to be yourself around people and not put on an act. I have a chatty, high energy personality with a bit of a potty mouth, Mike was great, he didn’t flinch, he actually matched my energy and we chatted like we’d been friends for years! This was something I NEVER felt at the other dealership that I’ve been loyal to for 25 years!!! Anyway, I told him my plan to trade/sell my current vehicle and lease a new one. I had my heart set on the 2026 Crosstrek and Mike informed me it was in stock so we proceeded to take a test drive. The crosstrek is a beautiful vehicle. It’s comfy, peppy has a lot of bells and whistles I was looking for and a few that I was pleasantly surprised I didn’t. We proceeded to finalize my purchase, yep we went from “I just have a few questions” to okay I’ll take it! Mike gave me the number I was looking for and I’ll admit I was skeptical to see how much that number was going to change once we got to the financing portion, we all know how this goes you get told one thing then once they run your credit it turns into a ( insert expletive here) show….I swear I was waiting to see when the “surprise hidden fees” were gonna show up and they never did! The number he gave me was the number I got!!! Yet another great experience with a new dealership. So now that all my paperwork is in order Mike brings me back to his office to take care of my insurance and registration…. Here we go again right? Wrong!!! They simply called my insurance agent and changed vehicles on my current policy, there was no “ oh why don’t you sit with our on site insurance agent to see if they can beat your current price” literally no additional BS. We set up my Subaru app and he gave me the tutorial on how to use it along with all the cool features in my car!!! I left there feeling calm and relieved that there was literally no stress! Overall this has been the ABSOLUTE BEST experience getting a new car!! If you have a fear of jumping ship from your current dealership to try something new, get your butt down to East Hills Subaru in Sayville!! Make sure you see Mike Chiofalo!!! Thank you again Mike 😊”

“We had such a good experience buying a car for my wife. Jason Behler really helps us understand everything that the car has to offer and gave us a really good deal. Everyone is really nice at the dealership and don’t forget you can bring your pets to make business with you.”

“I recently purchased a vehicle here and I couldn’t be happier with the entire experience. Bill went above and beyond to make sure every detail of the deal was perfect. He put in a tremendous amount of effort to help me secure an incredible steal on one of the last generation Outbacks, and his professionalism and dedication truly stood out. When it came to F&I, Diane was just as amazing. She made the process smooth, transparent, and completely stress free, ensuring I received the best possible terms without any pressure. Thanks to Bill and Darlene, the whole experience was flawless from start to finish. I’ve purchased many cars over the years, and this was by far one of the easiest and least time consuming experiences I’ve ever had. I walked away confident, satisfied, and genuinely grateful for the exceptional service!!!”

“This was my second car purchase in just 30 days, and somehow East Hills Subaru Sayville managed to top what was already an incredible experience. If I could give them 100 stars, I would. I’ve been buying cars for over 30 years, and too many times I’ve left dealerships feeling frustrated after hours of back and forth just to get what I thought was fair. That was absolutely not the case here. Everything about this experience was smooth, honest, and stress free. Dominique Liccione was my salesperson and she was amazing from start to finish. She’s kind, respectful, and truly genuine. She made me feel like I wasn’t just another deal, but a valued customer. This was my very first Subaru purchase, and I honestly wish I had come here sooner. I also want to recognize Nelson Peraza, the sales manager. There was a small misunderstanding from one of his team members during my intake, and Nelson personally stepped in, verified what happened, and made it right without hesitation. That type of character and follow through is rare, and it shows the integrity of this dealership. East Hills Subaru Sayville has earned a customer for life. Thank you.”