
Google Customer Reviews
Jenni Frommling
Jul 31, 2025
Rating:
“Tommy was great. He worked with me and got exactly what I wanted. I have bought several cars in the past and he was by far the fastest and most pleasant. Also, the financing guy was amazing. I will definitely be back for my next vehicle, it was worth the hour and a half drive for me to get there.”
John Mericle
Jun 27, 2025
Rating:
“I've always had great service from this location. I bought my Dart from them in 2016 and had a stress free experience plus got a good deal.
While I didn't purchase my 2023 Challenger from them, I definitely still use them for all my maintenance and service work. They've always been knowledgeable and expedient. Sue has always been terrific to work with and treated me well. She makes sure to call and explain everything if additional work is required beyond the original scope/estimate.
The only reason I didn't purchase my Challenger from them is because I was late to the party. I just bought it in January this year. Selection is sparse so I had to drive to Columbus to find one.
I'd highly recommend them to anyone in the area looking to purchase a vehicle or have service work performed.”
Mike Krueger
May 13, 2025
Rating:
“I cannot express how pleased I am with the entire Service Department and especially Will Lyons in the Collision Department. I dropped my truck off while I was on vacation, and they changed the oil and rotated the tires (it was about 37% cheaper than a year and a half ago). I also had some minor damage to my right front fender flare and the outer edge of my bumper. Will quoted me two separate prices and told me that he would reach out to me before he went any further that the buffing repair to see if I was pleased with that - I was pleasantly surprised. The work was done by Friday when I got back from vacation and the work was EXCELLENT!
He could have easily told me that it needed the deeper repair and charged me twice as much as the initial repair. I'm certain a local body shop would have raked me over the coals and just cashed in on my mistake of scraping the truck in the first place>
I would highly recommend New Carlisle Dodge to anyone for any service work, body work, or just to purchase a new/used vehicle. Everyone there seems to take pride in their company and their customers.
THANK YOU ALL!!”
Ralph Underwood
Jan 2, 2025
Rating:
“What a great dealership I wish I would have found them many years ago. The customer service is just fantastic. Matt the Service Manager and Scott the New Car Sales Manager are both one of a kind. You could not ask for better people to work with.
I was in the dealership several times and I did not hear not one negative comment from any employee. They are more like family than a team.
After several visits I ended up purchasing a 2024 Jeep Gladiator at a great price and I love it.
I want to thank Matt and Scott for a truly great experience.”
Ryan Barrows
Apr 21, 2024
Rating:
“I would highly recommend this dealership. The staff are all very knowledgeable, very respectful, and will work to get you what you need. I had such a great experience purchasing my car, that I sent my wife up there the next day to get a vehicle as well. Thanks all for hard work and dedication you put forth to make this easy on your customers!”