CarMax Columbus Sawmill

4.4 Google
Open Today:

12:00 PM - 7:00 PM

Google Customer Reviews

Dan McFarland

Mar 4, 2026

Rating:

“First and foremost, I’d like to say that I had another excellent experience at CarMax. From evaluating my trade-in to taking final delivery, every step of the process was smooth. The ease of accomplishing what could be a very complex process and the professionalism of my sales team was unmatched anywhere else in the industry. Eric Bender and Kevin O’Brien listened, helped, and made it happen, easily and quickly. I just completed the purchase of another amazing vehicle from my CarMax on Farmers Drive in Columbus, Ohio. Using carmax.com I located a vehicle in Dayton Ohio that I had to have, or at least had to see. They transferred it to my location ASAP. It was perfect. Thank you for all of your help and I look forward to doing business with you in the future.”

JamesF

Feb 23, 2026

Rating:

“Overall it was an enjoyable experience & we purchased the Pilot & paid for it in full. Our only concern was we paid to have this vehicle shipped from another CarMax location in another state. Once it arrived & we test drove it there was an expectation from sales that we were going to purchase on the spot right then & there. If customer finds the vehicle, pays to have it shipped from another location there should be a 48-72 hour window for prospective buyer to test drive, discuss it at home & think about for proper due diligence before making final decision to buy or not. Other than that it was a solid & positive buying experience.”

Praveen Sai Kumar VJ

Feb 18, 2026

Rating:

“CarMax made selling my car easy. The staff were polite, transparent, and professional the entire time. The appraisal felt fair and clearly explained, and the offer came in at the best price(I was personally satisfied). No pressure tactics, no last-minute surprises—just a clean, organized process that respected my time. Highly recommend if you want a straightforward sale.”

tim r

Jan 23, 2026

Rating:

“RAMPs DOWN while driving!! Car max hauler on the road in Dublin Ohio today Jan 22 11am on Snouffer at Sawmill with Ramps down!!! Illegal and extremely unsafe. Was heading north on Sawmill to get onto 270. Driver needs reprimanded snd retrained!”

Mimi Johnston

Oct 20, 2025

Rating:

“My customer service experience was 10/10. Eric was 100% committed to getting me exactly what I wanted, rather than trying to make the biggest sale. Absolutely couldn’t have been any more of a pro! Ember was my business office person and made sure everything was done quickly and completely. This is my family’s 9th Carmax car (we bought our first in 1997). It definitely won’t be the last. - ML Johnston”