
Google Customer Reviews
Mark V
Nov 9, 2025
Rating:
“I enjoyed the entire car buying process with Carmax. Mr. Garen at Carmax Dayton was the nicest, most patient dealer rep I have ever worked with. There was no pressure, no haggling, and no stress. I found a rare and excellent deal on the perfect vehicle for my family.”
Mike Luttrell
Nov 4, 2025
Rating:
“Great experience overall! 10 day post purchase return policy made buying car buying experience less stressful. After some issues were discovered during post purchase inspection, CarMax took care of the issues without a hassle. Highly recommend!!”
Feretory
Sep 26, 2025
Rating:
“I used Carmax of Dayton for the first time to sell my father's vehicle. He was no longer driving and wanted to sell it. I had received an offer from a local dealership near the house and also got an online offer from Carmax which was a better offer than the local dealership. I took his car to Carmax of Dayton and after a tech looked over his car, drove it, etc., the Business Office issued a final offer, and they did not reduce the offer, it was the same as the online offer which was a very good price for my dad's 2014 vehicle with low miles 40K. The Business Office Associate made the process very easy. He handled my Power of Attorney paperwork to handle my father's business without issue. He answered any questions I had and walked me through the process. Once the paperwork started, I had a check in hand within 30-45 minutes (note: they issue bank drafts - which just means you have to deposit the check into your bank account, you can't simply go somewhere and cash it, it must first be deposited). The staff was very friendly and professional. My first time experience with Carmax of Dayton was positive, enough so, that I would consider using them again if I needed to sell a car. Also, if I were in the market to buy a used car I would visit them first, they seem very fair on pricing and have a huge selection of cars. I would give Carmax of Dayton an A++ based on my experience. Thank you, Carmax of Dayton!”
Becky Rudduck
Sep 7, 2025
Rating:
“No haggle, up-front prices and friendly staff. I didnt get that slimy feeling you get at a regular dealership. After Carvana tried to pull a fast one on us, CarMax was a breath of fresh air. Mark was wonderful to work with, and I didn't feel pressured at all. The paperwork ladies were friendly, efficient, and very up-beat. I LOVE my car! Highly recommend!”
Joshua
Jun 27, 2025
Rating:
“My First 2023 Dodge Challenger Purchase Through CarMax – A Wonderful Experience!
I recently purchased my first 2023 Dodge Challenger through CarMax, and I couldn't be happier with the entire process. From start to finish, the experience was smooth, professional, and stress-free. The staff was friendly, knowledgeable, and attentive to my needs, making sure I found the perfect car that fit my style and preferences.
The vehicle itself is fantastic — powerful, stylish, and packed with features that make every drive exciting. I appreciated the transparency in pricing and the straightforward financing options, which made the whole process easy to understand.
Overall, I highly recommend CarMax for anyone looking to buy a vehicle. My first experience was truly wonderful, and I look forward to many miles of driving my new Challenger!”