
Google Customer Reviews
Jennifer Barlow
Jan 14, 2026
Rating:
“My husband and I were looking to purchase a new car when he suggested CarMax. I was a bit skeptical, having been to other…shadier places in the past, and not having the best of luck.
CarMax blew my expectations away. We walked in, and even though we didn’t have an appointment, we were immediately seated with Jesse. He was kind and friendly throughout the entire process. He explained every detail to us, making sure we knew all our options and didn’t have any questions.
He wasn’t pushy, but guided us the whole way. He even fielded about a thousand questions from my six year old with patience and ease.
We could not be more pleased with our experience!”
Ryan Stacy
Jan 7, 2026
Rating:
“I have been selling cars for over ten years, and I wanted to take a moment to speak about my experience here at Carmax Dayton. Carmax had the best selection of vehicle that I wanted. I found a car, inquired, did the pre-qualification, and immediately was contacted by my Sales Associate, Fallon. I highly recommend that anyone doing business at this store, asks for him. He was prompt, listened to my wants and concerns, and helped me navigate the entire process seamlessly. It's not often that I run into another Salesperson that cares about their customers as much as I do. He absolutely killed it. I showed up for my appointment, the car was clean and I immediately went in to sign papers. Thanks Fallon! Keep up the great work!”
Mark Newkirk
Dec 21, 2025
Rating:
“I had a great shopping experience Car Max. I came looking for a truck that would fit in my garage. Fallon found a Nissan Frontier that had every option that I wanted. Price was good and the offer for my truck was satisfactory. He had it shipped in from Cincinnati and when it arrived, I test drove it and bought it on the spot. Everyone was extremely nice to me and I love my new truck,”
Becky Rudduck
Sep 7, 2025
Rating:
“No haggle, up-front prices and friendly staff. I didnt get that slimy feeling you get at a regular dealership. After Carvana tried to pull a fast one on us, CarMax was a breath of fresh air. Mark was wonderful to work with, and I didn't feel pressured at all. The paperwork ladies were friendly, efficient, and very up-beat. I LOVE my car! Highly recommend!”
Joshua
Jun 27, 2025
Rating:
“My First 2023 Dodge Challenger Purchase Through CarMax – A Wonderful Experience!
I recently purchased my first 2023 Dodge Challenger through CarMax, and I couldn't be happier with the entire process. From start to finish, the experience was smooth, professional, and stress-free. The staff was friendly, knowledgeable, and attentive to my needs, making sure I found the perfect car that fit my style and preferences.
The vehicle itself is fantastic — powerful, stylish, and packed with features that make every drive exciting. I appreciated the transparency in pricing and the straightforward financing options, which made the whole process easy to understand.
Overall, I highly recommend CarMax for anyone looking to buy a vehicle. My first experience was truly wonderful, and I look forward to many miles of driving my new Challenger!”