
Google Customer Reviews
Nichole Fuhrman
Nov 10, 2025
Rating:
“I had such a great experience at McCoy’s Auto Sales! Corey helped me find my dream car, and it was spotless inside and out. He was super professional and worked hard to get me the best loan deal possible. He also took the time to explain all the paperwork in a way that actually made sense, which I really appreciated.
The place itself was super clean, welcoming, and family-friendly — and the two adorable cats in the office made it even better! My toddler was honestly very bored and ready to be done, but Corey was so patient and kind, and helped make the process go as smoothly (and quickly!) as possible.
There were no hidden issues with the car at all. Corey was totally honest and upfront about the previous ownership and maintenance history. I couldn’t be happier with the whole experience and definitely recommend McCoy’s Auto Sales to anyone looking for a reliable place to buy a car!”
Joshua Markelwitz
Jul 24, 2025
Rating:
“I have been looking for a truck for several months now. I have been working in concrete construction for about 5 months, and though I truly loved my 2014 KIA Forte5; it unfortunately could not do what I needed a vehicle to do.
I've been all over Fayetteville, Shippensburg and Chambersburg - hunting and searching for the truck that would best serve my need, a few of my wants, and that would fit within my budget. Everywhere I went, I would find something, only for the door of opportunity to be slammed in my face. I even had one dealership low ball me on the trade-in value of my KIA and try to offer me $800.
I was getting very discouraged. Then, while at my bank, my financial adviser (she who I refer to as the Finance Guru) suggested that I go to McCoy's Auto Sales and see what they have. I am so glad I listened to her. From the moment I got there Mike was super friendly and helpful. He asked the right questions and together, we found a truck that would fit what I needed and what I was looking for. Sadly, when I came back a few days later, someone had beat me to that particular truck. But that didn't deter Mike or Corey. They worked with me and we went through the trucks they had available until we truly found the ONE. Once we found the truck I wanted, Corey worked tirelessly with the banks until we were able to come to terms and get the financing for the truck. I am now the proud owner of a 2019 Ford F-150 STX and I absolutely love my truck!!!! I will be driving this beast for years to come.
Corey and Mike are the kinds of people you want to meet when you're out looking for a vehicle. They make you feel welcome from the start. No pressure, they want to help you find what it is you're looking for. Should the day ever come that I will need to trade-in this vehicle, the first place I am going to is McCoy's. I even have a few friends currently in the market for a vehicle and the first place I told them to try was McCoy's. Corey and Mike have truly earned my respect and trust and I absolutely believe are the best in the business.”
Steve Foster
Feb 7, 2025
Rating:
“After shopping around at my local dealers only to get the “run around” and trying to talk me into something with several noticeable problems that they made excuses for not knowing I was ASE certified even though I’m not a auto technician by trade a coworker told me about McCoy Auto Sales and had bought their vehicle there after a previous dealer gave them the run around. Mike at McCoy was very helpful and upfront about the truck I saw on their website. Even though I was about an hour away, I really like the truck so drove down to take a look. Truck was just as advertised and was very pleasant to work with. I told Mike what my down payment would be and he got it financed without the hassle of needing more for a down payment and/or a huge monthly payment. Very pleased with my experience with Mike and Corey and with the truck. Definitely recommend and was worth the drive!! Update. I’m not sure yet, but I might change my review after I found a break on this truck that was in very bad shape so bad that there’s no way that after the last inspection approximately eight months ago that it got that bad. Actually lost breaking capability one night luckily I’m experienced enough to know how to handle that situation and got back home without a problem.
Another update. I did call and leave a message, but have never heard back. Happy to say though that I did the necessary repairs and been back on the road for awhile now.”
Jacob Eberhart
Jan 16, 2025
Rating:
“Yesterday I found a truck online that I really liked. I drove 45 minutes to this dealer to check it out not knowing anything about the dealership itself. I've bought quite a few vehicles over the years both new and used. And I've used many different dealers over the years. This is by far one of the best places I've worked with. The process was very simple and hassle free. There was absolutely zero sales pressure from Josh (owner). Once I decided to make the purchase, Corey made the paperwork a breeze. They will definitely be getting my business again in the future. Thanks again Josh and Corey!”
Amanda Lynn
Jul 31, 2024
Rating:
“I went on a whim today to see if my credit would be good enough to sign on a truck to pull our camper. My husband and I work on the road and live in GA. Josh and Cory were so nice and got me approved on the exact truck we were looking for! I made sure to ask that they not run my credit to death, and they only inquired 1 time. I've had GA car salesmen run my credit through a system up to 12 times... dropping my hard earned credit score. I appreciate everything Josh and Cory did for me today and highly recommend them to anyone who wants to try financing a vehicle. Thankyou McCoy Auto so much for everything today! ...and who knows where my job will take me; I may be back! ❤️”